If you or a family member are being kept in hospital or a care home, there are strict legal rules about when and how that can happen. If those rules are not followed, the detention may be unlawful.
Our specialist mental health solicitors advise patients detained under section, informal (voluntary) patients who are not being allowed to leave, and families concerned about a relative in a care home. We can check whether the detention is lawful and, if necessary, represent you in an unlawful detention claim.
Led by Partner Sarah Griffiths-Jones, our team acts for clients across England and Wales. Advice is normally free under legal aid (the Legal Help scheme), subject to a means assessment.
When can a detention be unlawful?
When somebody is detained under mental health law, there are formalities involved to ensure that this is carried out lawfully. In some circumstances, these formalities are not complied with, or someone is “de facto” detained despite not being sectioned. This may mean they are being unlawfully detained.
Informal (voluntary) patients
If someone is voluntarily in hospital, they are allowed to leave. Hospital staff can only stop them using specific short-term holding powers under section 5 of the Mental Health Act: up to 72 hours by a doctor, or up to 6 hours by a nurse, while an assessment is arranged. If an informal patient is being prevented from leaving without one of these powers, or without being sectioned, they may be unlawfully detained.
Patients detained under the Mental Health Act
If a patient is detained under the Mental Health Act, it can be trickier to determine whether they are lawfully sectioned. Sometimes the initial sectioning process has not been complied with, or the patient’s section has not been renewed in time.
People in care homes and hospitals who lack capacity
If someone who lacks capacity is deprived of their liberty in a care home or hospital, a Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards (DoLS) authorisation must be in place. It can only be granted where the deprivation of liberty is in the person’s best interests, necessary to prevent harm to them, and a proportionate response to that risk. In other settings, such as supported living or the person’s own home, a deprivation of liberty must be authorised by the Court of Protection.
If the patient lacks capacity, they may be disoriented and ask to go home. It is not uncommon for people with dementia, for example, to forget where they are and why. It can understandably be distressing to hear a loved one in a care home say things such as “I want to be at home”.
If a care home resident keeps making these requests, or is actively trying to leave, it may be necessary to review their placement. Our Court of Protection solicitors can advise on challenging a deprivation of liberty. Legal aid for a challenge to a DoLS authorisation is not means-tested.
Speak to our team
We understand that unlawful detention can be an incredibly challenging and difficult process, for patients and families alike. We always treat every case with sensitivity, and our specialist team are on hand to support and guide you through it.
To speak to our Mental Health team, call 0333 023 7747 or email [email protected]
Frequently Asked Questions
A patient may be detained for different reasons, and the process will therefore be assessed on a case by case basis. Some example, however, are as follows:
Mental Capacity Act 2005
In cases where a person lacks mental capacity to make a decision about their care and/or residence, this decision can be made for them. This may be in the form of an extended hospital or residential care placement. This decision must only be made in instances where it is in the patients’ best interests. This process is referred to as a Deprivation of Liberty (DoL) under the Mental Capacity Act.
Processes must be followed, and social services must ensure the correct steps are being taken to lawfully authorise a deprivation of liberty.
The patient who is deprived of their liberty may object to the decision. In such instances, they can have an independent review through the Court.
Mental Health Act 1983
Similar to the Mental Capacity Act 2005, a patient may be lawfully detained for assessment or treatment under the Mental Health Act 1983.
If a patient wishes to challenge this decision, they again have the right to an independent review through the Mental Health Tribunal.
If you believe that you, or your family member, are being unlawfully detained, we strongly advise that you seek legal advice. Our team can advise you of your rights if you are detained. This includes under Section or Informal (a voluntary patient). We can represent you in any subsequent unlawful detention claims, if necessary. You can call us on 0333 240 7373 or contact Reeds Solicitors LLP on [email protected].
It is easy to understand why so many of us to hypothesise that unlawful detention is something that applies to ‘prisoners’. Whilst the principle is the same for those who are detained under any circumstance, unlawful detention and false imprisonment are two different things.
Unlawful detention is where you are kept in hospital or a care home against your wishes and there is no statutory framework authorising your detention. False imprisonment generally applies to people who are wrongly detained at the police station or immigration detention centre, for instance.
The Care Act 2014 details that patients must not be detained, nor forced from their homes, because it is cheaper to keep them in a hospital or a care home than it is to provide at-home care.
It is the duty of social services to meet your assessed eligible care and support needs, no matter where you live. If you are told that you are remaining detained because the amount of care at home is less than you will be provided at the hospital or care home, you may challenge this. Social services are not allowed to say the care can be provided at a lower cost in your hospital or care home than at your residence.
If it can be proven that you have been unlawfully detained, then you be able to claim compensation. The amount as to which you will be eligible for may vary significantly depending on the evidence pertaining to:
- The conditions of the unlawful detention.
- The length of time you were detained for against your wishes.
- Any financial loss you have suffered as a result of the detention.
- Any injury or harm. This includes both physical and psychological.
It is important that people are lawfully detained because this ensures they are eligible for safeguards if they are objecting to their detention. This can be via the Mental Health Tribunal or the Court of Protection. Someone detained unlawfully does not have access to these safeguards.
If someone is unlawfully detained, they may be able to:
- Ask the detaining authority to authorise their detention in accordance with the law;
- Apply for a Judicial Review of their detention; or
- Apply for a writ of Habeas Corpus which compels the detaining authority to release somebody if they are not detained in accordance with the law.
These are all complex undertakings, and it is essential that you seek legal advice to determine whether you are lawfully detained and what options are available to you.
Someone can be detained under Sections 2 and 3 of the Mental Health Act on the recommendations of two doctors and an Approved Mental Health Professional (AMHP). The Section 2 can only last for 28 days, and the Section 3 can be indefinite but must be regularly renewed by the patient’s Responsible Clinician.
The initial sectioning process must comply with the requirements set out in Sections 11 and 12 of the Mental Health Act which includes:
- A discussion with the patient’s Nearest Relative,
- For one of the doctors to be S.12 approved in the diagnostics and treatment of mental disorders,
- For there to be no conflict of interest, and
- The sectioning process complying with certain time limits between recommendations.
A patient under Section 3 must also have their section renewed regularly, and the doctor must give adequate reasons for doing so on a prescribed form.
If any of these are in doubt, then the possibility of unlawful detention should be explored.
Get in touch
Information is processed in line with UK GDPR and our Privacy Policy